We continued to do the “Yankee Doodle” lesson with the next 5th grade class, but I invited my mentor, Jen Purdy to come to
watch so that I could get some feedback on how it could be improved. Rather
than tell me what went wrong and what went well, Jen asked me what I thought of
the lesson. I told her that I felt it had gone pretty well: I felt that my objectives
were mostly met, and my classroom management was getting better, too. I
was also proud of myself for being brave enough during the lesson to identify a
time when the students weren’t clapping the beat. Instead of moving on, I identified it and we fixed it.
However, I had noticed in teaching this time that the students
struggled when I asked them to improvise their own rhythm towards the end of the
lesson. This had also happened in my other lessons, but I hadn’t paid enough
attention to it. During this lesson, some students just kept the beat, instead
of improvising a rhythm. Others would just go crazy, not really doing any kind
of rhythm, just hitting the table.
Jen had noticed this too. I didn’t know how to fix it, but
Jen suggested that I give more rhythmic examples to the students before I let
them improvise. She also suggested that we could clap some notated rhythms to
help give the students some ideas. So when I came back to teach this lesson for a fourth time
to the final 5th grade class, I added these slides to my lesson:
During my lesson, we clapped some of these rhythms before I
let the class try to improvise their own. I think it helped all of the students
to create better rhythms. Of course, there were still some students who could’ve
used more help. If I had more time, I would’ve loved to walk around the room to assess their rhythms and perhaps help some of
the students who were still struggling. But I think that adding these slides to
my lesson did help a lot! I’m grateful to Jen for her suggestion to do so.
**********************************************************************************************
Link to view updated Google Slides
Link to listen to Class 3
Link to listen to Class 4
Link to view updated Google Slides
Link to listen to Class 3
Link to listen to Class 4
